US$17 billion question: why China and South Africa are so far apart on trade data

Whenever South African officials meet their Chinese counterparts to talk trade, the issue of the imbalance in China’s favour is almost certainly raised.
But a discrepancy in the data from the two sides makes it hard to assess the trade gap.

The latest Chinese customs data suggests that South Africa actually holds a surplus – exporting more to the world’s second-largest economy than it receives in return.

Advertisement

According to the numbers from Beijing, China recorded US$30.58 billion in imports from South Africa last year.

However, the South African data for the same period – via the United Nations International Trade Statistics Database, or UN Comtrade – shows the country shipped goods worth US$13.5 billion to China.

China sends mainly value-added manufactured goods like solar panels to South Africa. Photo: AFP
China sends mainly value-added manufactured goods like solar panels to South Africa. Photo: AFP

Observers said this multibillion-dollar statistical gap was a reflection of how the true flow of goods between nations could be masked by different reporting practices and “opaque” global commodity chains.

South China Morning Post

Related posts

Leave a Comment